Weichert Realtors
September 2025 Market Report

Andover NJ Real Estate

Sussex County Real Estate Market Analysis

Median Price

$395,000

+5.8%

Days on Market

32

days avg

Inventory

2.8 months

months

Market Trend

Strong

Balanced Market

Andover NJ Real Estate

Andover NJ Real Estate demonstrates steady growth and stability in Sussex County, with median home prices at $395,000 reflecting a 5.8% increase year-over-year. This consistent appreciation highlights the area's appeal as a peaceful residential community that offers excellent value compared to neighboring markets, making it particularly attractive to first-time buyers and families seeking affordable housing options.

The market's performance is supported by Andover's unique combination of rural charm and accessibility. Located just 40 miles from New York City, the town provides an ideal balance for commuters who desire a tranquil lifestyle without sacrificing convenience. With homes selling in an average of 32 days, the market shows healthy demand while maintaining reasonable inventory levels at 2.8 months.

Current economic factors contributing to Andover's market strength include low unemployment in the region, continued remote work flexibility, and the area's reputation for excellent schools and low crime rates. These fundamentals suggest sustained growth potential, positioning Andover as a smart choice for long-term real estate investment.

Key Market Insights

  • Affordable entry point compared to surrounding areas
  • Strong commuter appeal with 40-mile NYC proximity
  • Balanced inventory supports steady market conditions
  • Low crime rates and excellent schools attract families
  • Rural charm with modern conveniences
  • Consistent appreciation without market volatility

Ready to Navigate Andover's Market?

Get personalized guidance based on the latest market data and trends. Whether you're buying, selling, or investing in Sussex County, I provide the expertise to help you succeed.

Andover NJ Real Estate Market Statistics

Current Andover real estate conditions and performance metrics

Median Sale Price

$395,000

+5.8%

Average sale price for single-family homes

Days on Market

32

-8%

Average time to sell a home

Active Listings

28

+12%

Current homes available for sale

Homes Sold

24

+15%

Total sales in last 30 days

Market Performance

Andover real estate trends and market composition analysis

Price Trends

Apr$382K
May$388K
Jun$391K
Jul$393K
Aug$395K
Sep$395K

Sales Activity

Apr20 sales
May22 sales
Jun23 sales
Jul24 sales
Aug23 sales
Sep24 sales

Market Composition

Single Family70%
Townhomes15%
Condos10%
Multi-Family5%

Market Momentum

Andover demonstrates strong market fundamentals with consistent price appreciation and healthy sales activity. The balanced inventory levels indicate a stable market environment with opportunities for both buyers and sellers.

Neighborhood Markets

Explore distinct neighborhoods across Andover with unique characteristics and market dynamics

Andover Borough

Most Walkable
Rising

Historic downtown area featuring Victorian homes with modern updates. Walkable community with local shops and services.

Avg Price

$365,000

Days on Market

28

Price Range

$280K - $450K

Monthly Sales

8

Explore Properties

Lake Aeroflex Area

Best Recreation
Rising

Waterfront properties with lake access and recreational opportunities. Peaceful setting with scenic views and outdoor activities.

Avg Price

$420,000

Days on Market

35

Price Range

$350K - $520K

Monthly Sales

6

Explore Properties

Andover Township

Stable

Rural countryside living with larger lots and modern homes. Privacy and space with convenient access to amenities.

Avg Price

$380,000

Days on Market

30

Price Range

$320K - $480K

Monthly Sales

12

Explore Properties

Sussex Branch Trail Area

Rising

Properties along scenic trail offering active outdoor lifestyle. Wooded lots with access to biking and hiking paths.

Avg Price

$410,000

Days on Market

33

Price Range

$340K - $500K

Monthly Sales

5

Explore Properties

Andover Market Overview

4

Active Neighborhoods

$393,750

Avg Area Price

32

Avg Days Listed

31

Total Monthly Sales

Find Your Perfect Neighborhood

Each neighborhood in Andover offers unique advantages and lifestyle options. Let me help you discover the perfect match for your needs and preferences.

Get Neighborhood Guide

Contact Us

We would be delighted to assist you with your luxury real estate needs.

Contact Cheryl

Phone

908.334.0971

Email

ctowey@weichert.com

Office

1625 NJ-10 East, Morris Plains, NJ 07950

I'm dedicated to providing you with personalized service for all your real estate needs in Hackettstown, Andover, Byram, Blairstown, Chester, and Washington.

Send a Message

Luxury Real Estate

Ready to Find Your Dream Home?

Let Cheryl Towey guide you through New Jersey's premier real estate market with expertise, dedication, and personalized service

250+

Homes Sold

10+

Years Experience

5.0

Client Rating