7 Best Places to Live in New Jersey, According to Real Estate Experts

New Jersey offers a diverse array of communities, from coastal retreats to historic boroughs, each with unique draws for homebuyers. Drawing from recent insights by real estate data providers and experts, this guide highlights seven standout locations.

These selections blend high median sale prices from PropertyShark's 2025 list of the nation's priciest ZIP codes—with six New Jersey spots making the top 100—and expert-recommended livability factors like schools, amenities, and lifestyle.

Whether you're eyeing luxury estates or family-friendly enclaves, these areas showcase the Garden State's appeal. Data reflects median sale prices through October 2025, emphasizing market trends without predicting future shifts.

Chester, NJ: Morris County's Historic Heartland Hideaway

Rounding out the seven, Chester Borough in Morris County emerges as a real estate favorite for its blend of colonial charm and modern convenience—often cited by locals and pros for livability over flash. With median home prices around $800,000 (per NeighborhoodScout 2025 data), it offers accessibility compared to coastal heavyweights, yet boasts a per capita income of $80,525, ranking wealthy by state standards.

Experts like those from RE/MAX highlight Chester's walkable downtown with boutiques, farms, and eateries like The Black River Barn. The West Morris Regional High School District scores top marks, and Black River County Park provides trails for hiking. Just 45 minutes from Manhattan via I-78, it's ideal for hybrid workers. Historic sites from the 1700s add whimsy—think Revolutionary War reenactments that keep history lively without the dust. For tailored searches in Chester, contact Cheryl Towey at realestatebycherylnj.com/contact.

Alpine, NJ: Bergen County's Pinnacle of Prestige

Alpine (ZIP 07620) claims the top spot on New Jersey's priciest list, with a record-breaking median sale price of $4.35 million—the first time a local ZIP has crossed the $4 million threshold. This Bergen County borough has held the state's No. 1 position for nine consecutive years, per PropertyShark. Real estate experts note its seclusion and celebrity allure, with sprawling estates on 1-5 acre lots offering privacy amid wooded hills.

Buyers here access top-rated schools in the Alpine Public School District and quick drives to Manhattan via the Palisades Interstate Parkway. Amenities include nearby Palisades Interstate Park for hiking and the Alpine Country Club for golf. A September 2025 sale of a waterfront residence for $17.7 million marked the state's highest in three years, per the New York Post and Mansion Global.

Deal, NJ: Monmouth County's Coastal Elegance

Tied for second in state rankings, Deal (ZIP 07723) hit a new high of $3.55 million in median sales, landing at No. 22 nationally. This Monmouth County enclave draws families and professionals with its oceanfront vibe and low-key luxury. Experts highlight the mix of renovated Tudors and modern builds along tree-lined streets, often with private beach access.

The area boasts strong schools through the Ocean Township district and proximity to Asbury Park's vibrant dining scene. Commuters appreciate the Garden State Parkway, just minutes away. With a population under 1,000, Deal maintains a quiet charm, ideal for those balancing shore life with urban escapes.

Stone Harbor, NJ: Cape May's Serene Shore Haven

Stone Harbor (ZIP 08247) ranks No. 57 nationally and third in New Jersey at $2.55 million median. Real estate pros praise this Cape May County gem for its family-oriented beaches and upscale shopping on 96th Street. Here, buyers find shingle-style homes and condos with bay or ocean views, emphasizing outdoor living with docks for boating.

The Stone Harbor School District earns high marks, and the town's 7-mile bike path connects to Wildwood Crest. Seasonal events like the Stone Harbor Bird Sanctuary tours add community flavor. As a year-round spot despite summer crowds, it suits remote workers with Philadelphia access via the Cape May-Lewes Ferry.

Short Hills, NJ: Essex County's Polished Suburb

At No. 69 nationally and $2.415 million median, Short Hills (ZIP 07078) set a fresh record in 2025. Experts from Travel + Leisure spotlight this Essex County hamlet for its elite schools in the Millburn Township District—one of New Jersey's best, and the Short Hills Mall for high-end retail. Properties range from colonial revamps to contemporary estates on wooded lots averaging an acre.

The area's South Mountain Reservation offers trails and a nature center, blending suburbia with green space. NJ Transit trains reach Manhattan in under an hour, appealing to finance pros. With low crime and diverse dining, Short Hills embodies refined daily living. Check inventory at realestatebycherylnj.com

Avalon, NJ: The Quiet Side of Jersey Shore Luxury

Avalon (ZIP 08202) clocks in at No. 75 with a $2.36 million median, a staple for Cape May buyers seeking understated elegance. Real estate analysts commend its wide beaches and "Seven Mile Island" nickname, where homes feature elevated designs for flood resilience and panoramic dune views.

The Avalon School District serves K-8 with strong academics, feeding into Stone Harbor High. Bike paths and the Avalon Fishing Pier cater to active lifestyles, while fresh seafood spots like The Princeton Bar & Grill define local flavor. Off-season tranquility draws retirees, with Atlantic City an easy drive.

Allenhurst, NJ: Monmouth's Emerging Beachfront Star

Debuting at No. 93 nationally with $2.15 million, Allenhurst (ZIP 07711) marks a milestone for Monmouth County. Experts view this as a rising contender, with Craftsman and Victorian homes near Deal's beaches but with more space and fewer crowds. The borough's private ocean access and no-commercial zoning preserve its residential focus.

Sundays in Allenhurst Public School emphasize small classes, and the community pool hosts summer events. Proximity to Monmouth University adds cultural perks. As a first-timer on the priciest list, it signals growing interest in walkable shore towns.

These spots illustrate New Jersey's range, from multimillion-dollar waterfronts to value-driven boroughs. Factors like schools, commutes, and recreation vary by need—consult local data for your fit.

For personalized guidance in Hackettstown, Andover, Byram, Blairstown, Chester, or Washington, reach Cheryl Towey of Weichert Realtors.